She lives with her parents, Harry and Debbie, her adopted brother Dixon whom she considers her best friend and her grandmother Tabitha. She later agrees to a date with him where there is a confrontation between her and Mark. The family relocated in order to care for Harry's mother Tabitha Jessica Walter. When that photo is sent throughout her school by Naomi, Annie has a resentment against Mark, but then forgives him. At the beginning of Season 2, they are all at a beach party when she meets up with Mark, a senior. In the second season, Annie breaks away from the group and becomes somewhat of a loner due to the secret she is hiding and the resentment Naomi has for her. In the season finale after prom, Annie is framed when Naomi's sister Jen ends up in bed with Liam.